Ernst Sauckel's "Exploitation" SpeechTranslated by Carlos W. PorterIntroductionMost Nuremberg Trial documents have never been translated into English in their entirety. Typically, a single paragraph or even sentence is taken out of context, often mistranslated, to offer "proof" of German crimes. The rest of the document is ignored; the correctness of the translation is never questioned. For example, the following quotations appear in a footnote on p. 948 of William L. Shirer's Rise and Fall of the Third Reich: "One of his [Sauckel's] first directives laid it down that the foreign workers were 'to be treated in such a way as to exploit them to the highest possible extent at the lowest conceivable degree of expenditure.' He admitted at Nuremberg that of all the millions of foreign workers "not even 200,000 came voluntarily." Sauckel was, of course, hanged at Nuremberg for his "slave labour policies." The second quotation comes from an unsigned document (124-R) stating that factory foremen were sent to concentration camps for giving their "slave workers" so much as a box on the ear; the first is a falsified translation of a single sentence, taken out of context, from a speech (016-PS) in which Sauckel is explaining the necessity for labour service by both Germans and foreigners, and is demanding the best possible treatment for his workers, both German and foreign! The verb "exploit" does not even appear in the sentence! The verb is to "bring forth." The original German reads: "Alle diese Menschen muessen so ernaehrt, untergebracht und behandelt werden, dass sie bei denkbar sparsamsten Einsatz die groesstmoeglichste Leistung hervorbringen." A better translation would be: "All these people must be fed, housed, and treated so as to bring forth the greatest possible production for the most economically conceivable industrial effort." "Einsatz" includes cost, but is actually much broader: it means the number of men at work. In this document, "eingesetzte Menschen", for example, means "people who have been put to work." The meaning is to achieve the highest possible production per man with the lowest possible number of workers, a perfectly ordinary sort of concept in any undertaking. The full text of the document is as follows (the sentence taken out of context has been underlined for emphasis): Translation of Document 016-PS, Nuremberg Trial Draft directive by Ernst Sauckel [cover letter to Alfred Rosenberg deleted] The Commissioner for the Four Year Plan The General Plenipotentiary for the Labour Service.20.4.42 The Labour Service ProgrammeOn Remembrance Day 1942, the Fuehrer announced to the German people the most gigantic and most difficult German military achievements in history. In addition to the heroic and victorious struggle against an enemy unprecedentedly superior in numbers and materiel, an enemy fighting with the courage of the most extreme desperation and the most bestial cruelty, there has been the endurance of a hard winter, without parallel in the history of the past 140 years, in terms of cold, ice, snows, and storms. Overcoming the unprecedented hardships caused by such a climate, and by such extraordinarily bad weather conditions, has turned our soldiers on the Eastern front, measured against all previous human and military achievements, of all time -- we may say without exaggeration -- into Supermen. These soldiers are now entitled to expect the homeland itself to bring forth a comparably powerful concentration of the forces of the nation in order to ensure final, complete, and the earliest possible victory. All related burdens and other necessary restrictions, even in nourishment, must be borne with proud determination, precisely in view of the example set by our soldiers. Our Greater German Army has shown an excess of heroism, endurance, and overcoming, on the Eastern front, in Africa, in the air, and on the sea. To ensure their victory under all circumstances, we must now ensure that they are supplied with increasingly better and more numerous weapons, material, and munitions, as the result of an increasingly greater production effort on the part of the entire German people, that is, of all creative workers, both intellect and manual, both men and women, and of all German youth. In this manner, the German homeland will make a decisive contribution to the destruction of our enemy's every hope of once again staving off total and final defeat. The purpose of the gigantic new labour service is to make use of all the hugely rich resources which the army, fighting under the leadership of Adolf Hitler, has achieved and consolidated to such a overwhelmingly rich extent, in order to strengthen the Army and feed the homeland. The raw materials and fertility of the conquered territories, and their manpower resources, must be perfectly and conscientiously utilized for the benefit of Germany and our allies through the labour service. Despite the fact that most able-bodied German people have already put their strength to work for the war economy in a manner worthy of the highest recognition, considerable additional reserves must still be found and made available under all circumstances. The decisive measure to implement this is the uniformly regulated and controlled labour service of the nation at war. To achieve this goal, the following principles must be stated and carried out.
Implementation of these principles for the labour service requires:
If the objective set by the Fuehrer is to be achieved, it can only be made possible through the simultaneous and earliest possible implementation of many different measures, all aiming at the same objective. Since, however, none of these measures may disrupt the others -- rather, they must complement each other in a sensible way -- it is absolutely necessary for all the agencies participating in this decisive task, in any manner -- in the Reich, its territories and municipalities, in the Party, state, and economy -- to proceed according to uniform guidelines. Thus, the labour service of the nation will make an extraordinary contribution to the earliest possible victorious conclusion of the war. It will also require the final effort of the German people in the homeland. It is for these German people -- for their maintenance, their freedom, their happiness, and for the betterment of their nourishment and the maintenance of their lives -- that this war is being fought. Basic principles:
But if we succeed, with the assistance of the Party in all districts, areas, and municipalities, in convincing all German workers, both the workers of the intellect and the workers of the hand, of the great significance of the labour service in deciding the war; if we succeed in caring for and in strengthening all German men, women, and youth, doing their duty in the labour service under extraordinarily difficult conditions, in the best possible way, with regards to their physical and spiritual powers of endurance; if we furthermore succeed, with the cooperation of the Party, in utilizing the service of prisoners of war and civilian workers, both men and women, of foreign blood, but without harm to our people -- yes, even to the greatest benefit of the war effort and the food industry, then the most difficult part of the task of the labour service will have been solved. The task and its solution (In accordance with the requirements of secrecy, the following contains no statements in terms of figures. I nevertheless ask you to believe that this is the greatest labour problem of all times, especially in terms of numbers.)
Under point B. 1-7, I have attempted to describe the exterior solution of the task of the German labour service under the present war situation. It is obvious that the possibilities indicated in these points must all be entirely exhausted. The abandonment of general compulsory service for all women and girls in no way means, however, that I have at all abandoned my intention to make able-bodied women and girls available for suitable service, wherever they can be used to the benefit our war economy, without violating the basic principles of the Fuehrer. This will be carried out in the closest cooperation with the agencies of the Party, the state, the army, and the economy, involved for this purpose. The labour service programme established in point 1-7 means quite the most gigantic labour service ever implemented by any people, and even in history. Adolf Hitler has, however, revealed to us, through the concept of National Socialism, that numbers are not the decisive factor in the life of a people. In addition to the huge numbers of people set to work, there is the productive capacity. This productive capacity is, in turn, dependent, not just on the calories which I make available to them in the form of food, but also upon the inner attitude, the will, as well as the life of the mind and the emotions of the people who have been set to work. In addition to the huge organizational problems which must be solved in the labour service in this war, there are also, therefore, the questions of food, housing, education, propaganda, and social care. Social care for German workers men and women There must be no doubt in the mind of any German person and National Socialist that the working German person, when he is correctly led, and given political and ideological guidance, in his conscientiousness at work, in his readiness to take the greatest efforts on himself, in his ability and his performance, towers high over all the other workers on earth. The district leaders of Adolf Hitler in the districts of the NSDAP entrusted to them, must therefore guarantee that -- with the help of all the installations and organizations of the Party in the now decisive stage of the war -- they will give the German working people the best political and ideological guidance which has ever existed in the history of human labour and in times of war. As the Plenipotentiary for the Labour Service, I am certain that all steps will be taken in this regard by the Party, both outside and inside of industry, through the utilization of all means of propaganda and education, through waves of collections, and through industrial appeals, to maintain the proper attitude and morale of the German worker, in keeping with the dignity of the homeland with regards to the front, in this hour which is to decide our fate, and which is also the sole precondition for meeting this huge challenge and winning the war. It will be my constant concern to see that the labour service authorities, as well as all industrial leaders, support the Party, and particularly the German Labour Front, which has a decisive and great task, in every way. Even when workers, men and women, are set to work in armament factories in their own localities, and can sleep and eat in their own homes and sleep with their family, they must be cared for in the most meticulous way. I will mention only: ensuring the coal and potato supply, and considering the approach routes to and from work. Lack of spring vegetables and other hardships of wartime, which get on people's nerves and harm our people's health, must thereby be equalized, so that all decent people and women may therefore derive all the more strength from realizing the National Socialist principles of the racial community, of social justice, and the necessity for common sacrifices, and faith and trust in the Fuehrer. The challenge will be, however, much more difficult when it involves caring for those millions of workers, both men and women, rendering services which they are not accustomed to, far from their own homes. This is a necessity of war. Such service can neither be restricted, nor can the related hardships be eliminated. Everything must be done for these racial comrades, both men and women, to make their lives more enjoyable and their work easier, insofar as possible. All these German people must be supported so as to be housed in decently furnished quarters under equally decent conditions insofar as possible, to permit them to enjoy comradeship in their leisure time, through the Party and through the Labour Front, and to receive their coupons and so on, at the correct time. In this regard in particular, the "Politeness" Action of Reichs Leader Dr. Goebbels must be binding on all labour offices and all economic and food offices to the highest degree. Wherever German working people, whether men or women, are housed in camps, these camps must represent perfect examples of German cleanliness, order, and health care. German industries and the German economy must spare no sacrifice to make life tolerable for all those racial comrades, both men and women, who are housed in camps far from their own homes and families, on the basis of compulsory service. Just as in the German Army, the German soldier, in his company, considers perfect order with regards to both his outer needs and his character as a German soldier to be a matter of course, in a manner which raises him above the soldiers of all other peoples in his military qualities, this must also be possible for the working German people, in a manner suitably adapted to the labour service. Care for working German people in the armaments industries, in the war economy and the camps, must therefore be fundamentally guaranteed by German labour front to the most perfect degree. The more widespread utilization of women and girls outside their localities and away from their families must basically proceed according to the model of the women's labour service with regards to housing and care. Prisoners of war and foreign workersThe utilization without exception of all prisoners of war, as well as the importation of huge numbers of new foreign civilian workers, both men and women, has become an indisputable necessary in meeting the challenges of the labour service in this war. All these people must be fed, housed, and treated so as to bring forth the greatest possible production for the most economically conceivable industrial effort. For the Germans, it always has been a matter of course to treat a defeated enemy -- even when he has been our cruellest and most irreconcilable enemy -- without any cruelty or cheap trickery, to treat him correctly and humanely, even when we expect useful production from him. As long as the German armaments industry did not urgently require it, the importation of both Soviet prisoners of war, as well as civilian workers, both men and women, from the Soviet territories, was to be dispensed with under all circumstances. But that is no longer possible now. The manpower of these peoples must be utilized to the greatest extent. I have therefore, as my first step, regulated the nourishment, housing, and treatment of these foreign working people with the responsible superior authorities of the Reich, and with the approval of the Fuehrer and the Reichsmarshal of the Greater German Reich, so that optimal labour production may be demanded from them, and can also be obtained from them. Please remember, in so doing, that even a machine can only produce what I make available to it with in terms of fuel, lubricant, and maintenance. How many more requirements must be taken into consideration with a human being, even if he is of a primitive type and race, compared to a machine. I could not take responsibility before the German people for the importation of huge numbers of such people into Germany if, instead of bringing forth highly necessary and useful production, they one day become the heaviest burden or even become hazardous to the health of the German people, due to failings in nourishment, housing, and treatment. The most meticulous principles of German cleanliness, order, and hygiene must therefore apply in the Russian camps as well. Only in this way will it be possible, without all false sentimentality, to ensure the highest benefits from this service as well, in terms of armaments for the fighting front and for the military food economy. The necessary instructions for the nourishment, housing, and treatment of people from the East have already been issued to the responsible authorities of the police, war economy, and agricultural offices; in addition, I am now requesting the districts of the NSDAP to support me to the utmost in this matter, to avoid everything which may result in harm to the German people from this service. Members of racially related peoples and [German-] allied and friendly nations working in Germany should be treated and cared for with particular care. We must avoid everything which could make the stay and the work of foreign men and women doing service in Germany more difficult, or even cause unnecessary suffering, under the restrictions caused by the conditions and hardships of war. We are greatly dependent upon their good will and their manpower. It is therefore in keeping with the laws of reason to make their stay and their work in Germany as tolerable as possible, without compromising ourselves. This must, for example, be realized by making concessions to them with regards to their national or racial habits in food, housing, use of their leisure afternoons, etc., insofar as conditions permit, taking the situation of our own people into account. It is entirely possible that, if the authorities of the labour service, the general and interior administration, Party, and labour front, cooperate closely in the service of foreign men and women workers, with complete understanding and in close cooperation, in addition to the huge benefits which this mass service of millions of prisoners of war and foreign civilian workers may bring forth for the German war effort and the agricultural economy, just as great an advantage may accrue to the propaganda of the National Socialist Greater German Reich and its prestige in the world. Contrariwise, if the cooperation of all forces is not ensured, and if these problems are not eliminated by all authorities in the most meticulous detail, the greatest harm may result for our war economy. I therefore ask you, in conclusion, to pay exact attention to the following principles:
I would, therefore, most sincerely as well as most emphatically like to make it a duty for all German men and women wishing to cooperate decisively in the labour service, to take the most heartfelt account of all these necessities, decisions, and measures, according to the old National Socialist principle: Nothing for ourselves, everything for the Fuehrer and his work, that is, for the future of our people! Fritz Sauckel Note: Under the 4th Hague Convention, the Germans were entitled to utilize lower-ranking prisoners of war and resistance members for their labour, and to conscript civilian labour "for the needs of the army of occupation"; what the latter actually means in practice is somewhat unclear. In view of the scope of Allied war crimes and atrocities, it seems frivolous to argue the matter. De minimis non curat lex. end of text |
|
Committee for Open Debate on the
Holocaust, Bradley R. Smith, Director - Post Office Box 439016,
San Ysidro, CA 92143 |