
Helicopters at Treblinka?
Dear AnswerMan,
Both the 1971 and the 1996 edition of Michael Elkins' book *Forged
in Fury* include a passage that describes the aftermath of the Aug.
2, 1943 uprising at the Treblinka concentration camp in Poland. Both
editions describe the hunt for the Treblinka escapees--its Jewish inmates--in
these terms:
"For four days, the Germans prowled the forest, tracing the
Jews with packs of hunting dogs, spotting them with helicopters, burning
them out of the underbrush with flamethrowers, killing them on the spot,
wherever they were found. Of the 180 Jews in the forest, only 18 survived..."
It's the reference to "helicopters" in the Elkins account
that I find problematic. Were there in fact helicopters deployed by
the Treblinka authorities to "spot" and track down the escapees or was
Elkins--as so often happens--winking in the direction of Hollywood?
Might not this have been a case of a typical *MASH* or Vietnam War scenario
transposed to an earlier epoch for the sake of an added dramatic effect?
O. Slepokura
AnswerMan
Replies:
THE FIRST PROTOTYPE OF A HELICOPTER, or airplane using lift from
horizontal rotors, was made by the Russian Igor Sikorsky in 1909. Sikorsky
emigrated to the United States after the Revolution of 1917, developing
the first helicopter in the US in 1939, and so the helicopter has tended
to be associated above all with American air power.
But in fact Germany was not far behind. As early as 1926,
Anton Flettner, founder of the Flettner Aircraft Corporation, was developing
prototypes similar to modern helicopters. In 1940, the German navy requested
a small helicopter that could be used for reconnaissance at sea, the
ultimate product of this was the Flettner FL-282 "Kolibri" (Hummingbird),
a very successful aircraft. But only about two dozen were built, and,
like most helicopters, the Kolibri had a short flight range of about
100 miles. Therefore, while the Germans indeed had helicopters in World
War Two, it is extremely unlikely that they were used for land reconnaissance
much less for extended search and destroy operations. Schiffer Publications
of Aglen, PA has two volumes devoted to German helicopters, Heinz Nowarra's
"German Helicopters, 1928-1945", and "The Luftwaffe Profile Series --
Volume 6: Flettner FL 282", both at a modest price.
While it is unlikely that a helicopter would have been available
in Eastern Poland, the Germans did have a widely used scouting plane,
the Fieseler Storch, which in at least one case was confused with a
helicopter, although it didn't look anything like one.
In 1960, the West German authorities finally succeeded in
interrogating August Becker, the author of a famous letter, introduced
at the IMT as PS-501, which is crucial to the claim of gassing vans.
Becker had apparently dropped out of sight since the war, since he had
never been asked to corroborate his letter at Nuremberg or any other
trials. In the course of his interrogation, he claimed that there was
an extermination camp at Minsk (contradicting the standard version)
and also that he flew to Minsk on a helicopter -- but then he corrected
himself and said it was a Fieseler Storch.
On the basis of this interrogation, the West German authorities
decided that Becker was unfit to stand trial or imprisonment. (consult
Klee, "The Good Old Days", p. 68ff, 284, 289).
AnswerMan's educated guess is that Elkins was simply repeating
what someone had told him about "German helicopters" which were probably
confused with Fieseler Storch scouting planes. Of course, you may ask,
is it really possible for someone to confuse a scouting plane with a
helicopter? Well, it's hard to say, but such a confusion was evidently
good enough to make August Becker incompetent to stand trial.
|