
What happened to Europe's Jews?
Dear AnswerMan,
If the Jews of Europe were not exterminated during the Holocaust,
I'd like to know what happened to the millions who once lived there.
Pauline Friedman
AnswerMan
Replies:
Because this question deals with a large subgroup within the much
larger population of Europe during a major war, there is no simple single
answer to this question. Each person swept up in World War II has their
own tale to tell.
Nevertheless, some generalizations can be made as to why communities
of Jews existing in various regions of Europe before the war started
were no longer there when the war ended. These can be broken down by
chronology and region.
During the period between 1933 and 1940, the official German policy
toward the Jews within its sphere was to pressure them to emigrate.
Hundred of thousands of Jews left Germany, Austria, and Czechoslovakia
as it became increasingly difficult for them to work within their chosen
professions. Because of Nationalist government policies in Poland before
the start of the war, there was heavy emigration of Jews from that area
as well before the war started. The destinations for these emigrating
Jews included Palestine, North America, South America, Great Britain,
France, and The Netherlands.
Once the war in Europe commenced with the German invasion of Poland
-- followed shortly by the Russian invasion of the Eastern half of Poland
-- populations in this area of the continent began to shift. Soon thereafter,
German policy toward the Jews shifted as well.
When Germany invaded Poland from the west, Russia invaded Poland
from the east. The Soviet also invaded and took control of the Baltic
countries during this period. Nationalist movements in these countries
were quickly and brutally suppressed by the occupying Communists which
established the context for what happened next.
It must be kept in mind that the bulk of Europe's Jews lived in Eastern
Europe before the war started and that these same areas came under Communist
control when the war ended.
In 1939 France and Great Britain declared war on Germany over the
invasion of Poland and in 1940 Germany invaded France. After the French
surrender, the Nazis toyed with the idea of establishing a ghetto for
Europe's Jews on Madagascar, a French colonial possession. This idea
was abandoned because of British naval control of the Atlantic Ocean.
The following year Nazi Germany turned eastward once more and invaded
Russia capturing huge areas of land.
As the German army marched eastward, and even before, the Soviets
under Stalin deported millions of civilians from the areas soon to be
under German control into the Russian interior--to work in large industrial
complexes constructed in the Ural mountains. Up to twenty-two million
persons, or one third of the local population living in these areas
of occupied Soviet territory were either evacuated or conscripted into
Stalin's military. Since the density of Jews in these areas were higher
than elsewhere, it can be assumed that over a million Jews who would
have otherwise fallen under Nazi control did not. In addition, a million
Polish Jews escaped to the Soviet interior ahead of invading Germans.
Along with the retreat of the Red Army and the advance of the German
Army came attacks on local Jews who did not retreat with the Communists.
These pogroms were both spontaneous and encouraged by the Nazis. This
happened in the Baltic countries in particular which had suffered Soviet
occupation for over a year. The abuse suffered under the Soviets was
closely associated in the minds of the local population with Jews who
were seen as closely cooperating with the occupation. When the commissars
left the Jews were attacked.
At the same time, captured Jewish political commissars and irregular
guerrilla forces were summarily executed by the Nazi political police
under orders from Berlin.
From the time of the invasion of Soviet territory to final reversal
of Nazi fortunes in the east in 1944, National Socialism dictated that
ghettoes and work camps be created in the depopulated regions in the
East under German control. During this time many Jews were stripped
of property and sent from German and German-occupied areas in the West
to the East. Entire families were deported to eastern ghettoes and resettled
there. Others were sent to work camps and factories to labor for the
German war effort.
A report estimating Jewish populations commissioned by the Nazi government
indicate it was believed that the number of Jews in the world at the
beginning of 1943 was approximately 15.9 million and that it had dropped
by 1.1 million since 1937. The number living under German control had
decreased by 3.9 million through emigration and deportation. 440,000
deaths in excess of births in German occupied areas during this period
contributed to the estimated decrease in world Jewry.
Starting in 1944, the Germans began conscripting labor from the ghettoes
at a greater rate. German factory workers were put into military service
and Jews were put into the factories to replace them. That spring several
hundred thousand Hungarian Jews were taken from Hungary and sent to
camps and factories around Europe to work for the German war effort.
As a result many communities were scattered and family members separated
from one another.
One has to keep in mind that there was a war going on. Tens of millions
of people were displaced as the contending armies swept back and forth
across the continent: First in 1941 then again in 1944 and 1945; This
included people of many different ethnic backgrounds, not just Jews.
They had no homes to which to return because of the war's destruction
or military confiscation.
In the wake of the war, several political movements moved Jews in
different directions. Communism in the east presented opportunities
to Jews for power and revenge. Traditional Jewish charity organizations
such as the Warburg's Joint Distribution Committee attempted to re-establish
Jewish communities in Europe where they had existed in Western Europe
before the war. Zionism actively recruited settlers and soldiers for
Palestine and a future Israel among the camps of war refugees and displaced
persons. Opportunities in the United States and elsewhere attracted
many from Europe just as it had done before the war. Populations in
Europe were not static during this time and this included Jews -- especially
Jews.
Similarly for Germans; Danzig, Memel, and Koenigsberg were majority
German cities when the war began. They no longer were when the war ended.
What happened to the Germans who had lived there for centuries? What
happened to the Jews of Europe is the same as what happened to many
Germans. They became refugees with no place to call home. The trend
at the end of the war and in succeeding decades was for hundreds of
thousands and millions of Jews to quit Europe to go to Palestine and
the United States and the far corners of the globe.
Many of those that did stay in the east became active in the various
communist regimes established by the Soviets in eastern Europe. It was
common that they conceal their Jewishness by changing their names in
order to give these governments a more popular image. Even so, pogroms
in reaction to communist rule occurred in Poland, Hungary, and elsewhere
in the decades following the Communist military victories there. As
a result, many Jews continued to emigrate from eastern Europe after
the war ended.
In summary, what happened to the millions of Jews that once lived
in Europe falls into these categories; The majority emigrated to other
parts of the world; A large fraction stayed in Eastern Europe which
came under Soviet control; Another fraction, probably on the order of
one million died during the war in Nazi camps, in Soviet camps, in Soviet
military service, in pogroms, in German anti-partisan actions which
included reprisal killings, or of disease and privation.
Bibliography
Calvocoressi and Wint: TOTAL WAR Volume I: The War in
the West (1972)
Challen:RICHARD KORHERR AND HIS REPORTS (1993)
de Zayas: NEMESIS AT POTSDAM: The Expulsion of the Germans
from the East (1988)
de Zayas: THE WEHRMACHT WAR CRIMES BUREAU, 1939-1945 (1995)
Dressen, Klee, and Riess: "THE GOOD OLD DAYS:" The Holocaust
as Seen by Its Perpetrators and Bystanders (1991)
Gehlen: THE SERVICE: The Memoirs of General Reinhard Gehlen
(1972)
Irving: UPRISING: One Nation's Nightmare: Hungary 1956
(1981)
Sack: AN EYE FOR AN EYE: The Untold Story of Jewish Revenge
Against the Germans in 1945 (1993)
Sanning: THE DISSOLUTION OF EASTERN EUROPEAN JEWRY (1983)
Schatz: THE GENERATION: The Rise and Fall of the Jewish Communists
of Poland (1991) |